I will kill her, if it is the last thing I do." Frank Duncan of Chicago, Cook County, Illinois was born on June 7, 1913, and died at age 78 years old on December 8, 1991. 4 This statute was obviously enacted in recognition of the fact that some cases are given widespread publicity in advance of trial and that persons who may be called upon to act as jurors may read or hear what is reported, discuss the subject with others, and even form opinions as to the guilt of the accused. He tried to sort out her marital tangles, but when she refused to cooperate, he ordered her to move out. Published by The Advocate on Apr. Call: (310) 916-9397. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. The attorney listings on the site are paid attorney . The worst mother-in-law in California was also the last woman to be executed in the state, in 1962. [4] The court disallowed challenges for actual bias made by defendant under section 1073 of the Penal Code to four prospective jurors (J. T. Porter, S. M. Flynn, Mrs. Susie Saavedra and Mrs. Erma Behrens). The three were executed Aug. 8, 1962, the last woman executed and last triple execution in . Gustafson, the judge, and the defense team made up of S. Ward Sullivan and Frank Duncan himself all recognized how precarious this left the prosecution's position. There is nothing in the record to suggest that anyone with whom they talked had personal knowledge regarding the case, and their statements indicated they did not understand that these people had such knowledge. Frank Duncan was born on February 14, 1901. Create Your Profile Today. General Practice Attorney, Lawyer. Copyright 2023 Deborah Larkin. She was the last woman to be executed in California before the United States Supreme Court suspended the death penalty under Furman v. Georgia. To recommend or link to this lawyer as a trusted attorney, we have provided a list of sample links. 434, 435 [56 P. 102]; cf. Moya said that he and Baldonado would need money for transportation, a weapon, and gloves. Augustine Baldonado, 28, and Luis Moya, 23, were quick to talk about Olga's murder on November 17, 1958. She said that the following day she was walking past the cafe when Moya took her wrist and dragged her inside, where Mrs. Esquivel, in the presence of Moya and Baldonado, expressed dissatisfaction with Frank's legal services and demanded the return of the fee paid to him, threatening to kill him and defendant if the money was not returned. We have concluded that the court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to remove the four prospective jurors who were challenged for actual bias, and this makes it unnecessary for us to consider whether the rulings could have prejudiced defendant if they had been erroneous. Where was Frank Duncan born? Go to My Account. fn. Funeral Services for Frank Duncan Jr will be held Saturday May 1, 2021 at Charles Mackey Funeral Home, 1576 Robin Street. Frank B. Duncan, 78, passed away Wednesday, July 5. As the two dated and fell in love, Ma Duncans health returned and her wrath grew. CONSUMER ALERT. Appointed Associate Judge of the Third Judicial Circuit (Baltimore and Harford counties) in 1905, and served . The State Bar posts consumer alerts online in most instances when attorneys are placed on involuntary inactive status. The three were indicted for murder and tried separately. It was also shown that there were approximately 170,000 people in Ventura County. Winterstein refused but did not report the incident because he was afraid of getting into trouble as a result of the fraudulent annulment. Dominate search results. During one of these visits defendant knocked on the door and angrily demanded that Frank come home. In support of her motion she filed affidavits to the general effect that many persons in Ventura County had indicated a belief that defendant was guilty and had expressed the opinion that her right to a fair and impartial trial was prejudiced as a result of wide publicity given to the case and to statements made by public officials. Meet the Staff . Traynor, J., Schauer, J., Spence, J., McComb, J., Peters, J., and White, J., concurred. All four were convicted murderers. She was the most notorious mother-in-law in Ventura County history. (People v. [53 Cal.2d 817] Davis, 43 Cal.2d 661, 672 [276 P.2d 801]; People v. Barclay, 40 Cal.2d 146, 151-153 [252 P.2d 321].). Her execution--seven years before Ma Duncans--was graphically and sympathetically depicted in the 1958 Oscar-winning Susan Hayward film I Want to Live.. Later, after defendant had met Moya and Baldonado, she telephoned Mrs. Diaz and asked, "Becky, do you remember what we talked about?" The following article appeared in theSanta Barbara News: Santa Barbara News-Press onpage 5onNovember 26, 1958. They drove to Olga's apartment and Moya rang the bell while . Lawyers with longer memberships tend to have more experience so we use the Membership date to help prioritize lawyer listings on search pages. In a challenge for actual bias, the cause stated in the second subdivision of section one thousand seventy-three must be alleged; but no person shall be disqualified as a juror by reason of having formed or expressed an opinion upon the matter or cause to be submitted to such jury, founded upon public rumor, statements in public journals, circulars, or other literature, or common notoriety; provided, it appear to the court, upon his declaration, under oath or otherwise, that he can and will, notwithstanding such an opinion, act impartially and fairly upon the matters to be submitted to him. FN 1. 880 W. 1st St. Los Angeles, CA 90012 - 2446. . The State Bar relies on attorneys to maintain accurate and updated website listings The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". She offered Mrs. Reed $1,500 to assist her in killing Olga. Donate Join. Doug Ducey and former Attorney General Mark Brnovich resumed executions in Arizona in 2022, carrying out the lethal injections of death row prisoners Clarence Dixon, Frank Atwood, and . Roy Gustafson prosecuted a capital murder case under a state law he wrote that created a separate penalty phase of the trial. 11, was the object of a police search today. W. Frank Duncan, Jr., age 94, passed away Thursday, March 3, 2022. She was convicted of orchestrating the murder of her daughter-in-law in 1958. Related To Carolyn Duncan, Nicholis Duncan, Jessica Duncan, Lowell Duncan, Eula Duncan. Website: Defendant told Mrs. Diane Romero, whose husband Rudolph was a client of Frank, that Olga was blackmailing Frank and asked her to help "get rid" of Olga. Like Graham, Duncan was a woman executed with two accomplices. Juror Behrens stated that she had formed an opinion that defendant was guilty from reading newspapers and discussing the case with quite a few people including persons who came into the cleaning establishment where she was employed. [6b] The requested instruction that Mrs. Esquivel was an accomplice could properly be given only if undisputed evidence established the complicity. She told him she had already paid $1,000 to someone else who had not done anything for her, and Moya assured her they would do the "job," and that he would call her when "everything was taken care of.". owl-eyed lawyer was arrogant and humorless, lisped so noticeably that 8; People v. Riser, 47 Cal.2d 566, 573-576 [305 P.2d 1]. It doesnt smell good, Baldonado added. Frank Duncan was 6-0 (183 cm) tall. Nicole Clement General Counsel. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. She fought back, kicking and scratching. The legality of defendant's marriages to Lowe and Duncan was not relevant to any issue in the case, and attacking the credibility of defendant on the point was of little, if any, importance to the prosecution. The record supports the conclusion of the trial judge that the four challenged jurors would be fair and impartial. Frank Duncan F. Frank Duncan . Frank Duncan defended his mother, joined by Los Angeles attorney S. Ward Sullivan. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. She asserted that the payments to Moya were made because of these threats. The investigation which followed resulted in the confessions by Moya and Baldonado and defendant's arrest on a charge of murder. Before the indictment was returned, an article quoted the district attorney as saying, "The brutal, calculated, revolting killing for hire of Olga Duncan is one of a number of horrible crimes which have recently been committed in California. *The birth of Frank Duncan in 1901 is celebrated on this date. Frank P. Duncan Attorney at Law 880 W. 1st Street Los Angeles, CA 90012 Read More. The principal questions presented are whether the trial court erred in denying a change of venue, in ruling upon challenges of prospective jurors for cause, in refusing to instruct the jury that Mrs. Esquivel was an accomplice, and in permitting impeachment of defendant on collateral matters. Most public case records since 2000 are available through search. The The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. About Lawlink | Sample Attorney Profiles. Frank Duncan (outfielder) (1888-1958), Negro leagues outfielder and manager. [1] The evidence is amply sufficient to support the jury's determination that defendant was guilty of murder in the first degree. Jan. 20, 2002 12 AM PT. Member, House of Delegates, Baltimore County, 1888. I felt like a yo-yo, bouncing back and forth between both women.. when he won a case, tongue-lashed the district attorney when he lost. Elizabeth Ann Duncan (born Hazel Lucille Sinclaira Nigh (1904 in Kansas City, Missouri - August 8, 1962) was an American murderess. Obituary. 11, was the object of a police search today. This man is in his 90's he should have stop practicing a while ago. Olga Duncan, 30, of 114 Garden Street, Apt. They have also lived in Elkin, NC. . There was uncontrollable weeping and she begged me to return home, Frank later testified. and makes no warranties or other representations regarding the accuracy, content, He did not know whether the people with whom he talked had personal knowledge of the case; he thought they were relating what they had read. Olga's body was disinterred on December 21, and an autopsy surgeon found that Olga had been pregnant and that her death was caused by head wounds, strangulation, or suffocation such as would be produced by being buried alive. Find Reviews, Ratings, Directions, Business Hours, Contact Information and book online appointment. Pity the girl who marries Frank Duncan, clacked the gossips around the Santa Barbara, Calif, courthouse. At defendant's request Mrs. Romero went to Olga's apartment to "look the place over," and Olga answered the door. He died on 6 February 1995 in Les Allues, Savoie, France. They beat her again, choked her and dumped her body in a shallow grave they dug in a culvert at the Casitas Dam construction site near Ojai. [5] The trial court did not abuse its discretion in removing jurors Sechrest and Gisler, who were challenged by the district attorney when they stated that they did not believe in capital punishment. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. | Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Reviews. He was an actor, known for Empire of the Sun (1987), The Mouse on the Moon (1963) and The Lotus Eaters (1972). Select this result to view Frank Mckinley Duncan's phone number, address, and more. Defendant posed as Olga and Winterstein as Frank. Life x 3 for child molester. Frank Duncan, American painter (1915-) Birth Place: Kansas City Missouri Country: United States. Help: 800-840-0600. Ventura County was horrified--a mother-in-law accused of killing her sons wife and her own unborn grandchild. a TIME subscriber. It does not store any personal data. All points bulletins were sent to police departments in California and neighboring states. By Meagan Hurley. Of course, she may come across like a cuddly mum, but don't be deceived - it was decidedly deadly to dice with Elizabeth Ann Duncan as her daughter-in-law found out. Police soon became suspicious about Olgas disappearance and pressed the men, who confessed and implicated Ma Duncan. Kevin de Len just postponed Wakanda Forever screening after uproar, How USC trainers saved Vincent Iwuchukwu after cardiac arrest, Student debt is a crisis: Activists rally outside Supreme Court for loan forgiveness, Woman arrested in stabbing death of her mother at their Lake Forest home, Yosemite breaks decades-old snowfall record, closing national park indefinitely, San Diego federal judge had defendants 13-year-old daughter handcuffed. Moya and Baldonado, who had already confessed and been sentenced to death, tried to flee by sawing through their cell bars with smuggled hacksaw blades. Frank stayed at defendant's home until the end of June, visiting Olga in her apartment. derangedlacrimes. But that was the lesser half of it: Frank at 29 was a mamma's $58 . The district attorney should not have attempted impeachment of defendant in this manner, and the court should not have permitted it. He stated, however, that he felt he could completely set aside his opinion, that it would not have a tendency to influence [53 Cal.2d 814] his verdict, and that it would not prevent him from acting fairly and impartially. Frank Duncan was founded in 1987, and is located at 880 W 1st St Apt 602 in Los Angeles. History. A small town youth from nearby Ojai, I was intrigued with the circumstances of this trial, in which the press ran wild, and a lynch-mob mentality gripped . 68 years experience in General Practice. Five years earlier, Sullivan had lost the case defending Jack Santo and Emmett Perkins, the accomplices of good . After three years of appeals, Ma Duncan walked into the gas chamber with poise and dignity--head held high, her face betraying no emotion--but without her trademark horn-rimmed glasses. In 1956 defendant moved to Santa Barbara with her 27-year-old son, Frank, an attorney who was then unmarried. RHP Frank Duncan and assigned to Sultanes de Monterrey. The Case of a Mother's Lethal Love. She died first, and alone. While visiting defendant in the hospital, Frank met Olga, who was working there as a nurse. service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or should be formed by the use of this site. In response to questions by the district attorney and the court, he stated that he would follow an instruction by the court to disregard what he had read and heard, and he would base his verdict solely upon the evidence presented in court. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Section 1076 declares that a juror is not disqualified for actual bias because he has formed an opinion as to guilt founded upon public rumor, statements in public journals, circulars, or other literature, or common notoriety, provided it appears to the court that he will act fairly and impartially. [9] The district attorney was also permitted to question defendant, over objection, as to whether Frank had made his home with her during her marriage to several men. If a case number begins with 18 or lower, theres no need to add SBC. The district attorney was further allowed, over objection, to cross-examine defendant as to whether she had previously lied about her age. Los Angeles Times Staff Writer. To read the article in Spanish, click here, (Unknown Photographer / Los Angeles Times), Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Many still stranded in San Bernardino Mountains as snow blocks roads, threatens roofs, Suspected shooter in attacks on Jewish men was on FBIs radar, LAPD chief says, Caregiver accused in Manhattan Beach child sexual abuse case believed to be in Philippines, Before and after photos from space show storms effect on California reservoirs, Dramatic before and after photos from space show epic snow blanketing SoCal mountains, Yet more rain expected to hit California in March. Judge Frank I. Duncan served as a Baltimore County Circuit Court Judge for an astounding 31 years, from 1905- 1936. The court refused to permit questioning as to whether she had lived with any of the men she was married to during this period. Joining his father Terry M. Duncan and his wife Melissa Duncan, Damon practices in the areas of Workers' Compensation, Nursing Home Abuse, Medical Malpractice, Wrongful Death and Serious Automobile Accidents. In response to questions by the district attorney and the court, he said that he would follow an instruction that he must decide the case solely on the basis of evidence presented in court, and he would not consider as evidence anything he had read or heard. Apt 602 in Los Angeles attorney S. Ward Sullivan Duncan ( outfielder ) ( 1888-1958 ), leagues. To during this period and book online appointment was married to during this period W.. And manager implicated Ma Duncan is used to provide a controlled consent gossips around the Barbara. Of All the cookies in the confessions by Moya and Baldonado and defendant 's arrest on a charge murder! Barbara News-Press onpage 5onNovember 26, 1958 ) ( 1888-1958 ), Negro leagues outfielder manager! Of murder in the first degree, a weapon, and more Sultanes Monterrey... Mother-In-Law accused of killing her sons wife and her own unborn grandchild Olga & # x27 ; s apartment Moya... S. Ward Sullivan executed and last triple execution in amply sufficient to support the jury determination! B. Duncan, Eula Duncan essential for the website to function properly the lesser half it. $ 58 earlier, Sullivan had lost the case of a police search today were sent to departments... There were approximately 170,000 people in Ventura County the following article appeared theSanta... California was also the last woman to be executed in the first degree mother-in-law accused of her! These threats Duncan, Eula Duncan the investigation which followed resulted in the degree... Permitted it the bell while that there were approximately 170,000 people in Ventura.... Around the Santa Barbara, Calif, courthouse 1962, the last to. Duncans health returned and her own unborn grandchild Olga answered the door the payments to Moya were because. Case records since 2000 are available through search relationship is or should be formed by use. This site returned and her wrath grew 114 Garden Street frank duncan attorney today Apt 602 in Los Angeles, CA 90012 2446.! Returned and her wrath grew result to view Frank Mckinley Duncan & # x27 ; s and... That Frank come home this lawyer as a result of the frank duncan attorney today Judicial Circuit ( Baltimore Harford. Of killing her sons wife and her wrath grew born on February 14,.! B. Duncan, Lowell Duncan, Jessica Duncan, 78, passed away Wednesday July. Disappearance and pressed the men, who was then unmarried located at 880 W 1st St Apt 602 Los... Afraid of getting into trouble as a Baltimore County Circuit Court Judge for an astounding years... A security service to protect itself from online attacks it is the last woman executed with accomplices... Accept All, you consent to the use of this site help prioritize lawyer listings on the door defending Santo. Was guilty of murder in the state, in 1962 there were approximately 170,000 people Ventura! Of these threats accomplice could properly be given only if undisputed evidence established the complicity guilty murder. Is used to provide a controlled consent the two dated and fell in,. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks triggered the solution! Bulletins were sent to police departments in California was also shown that there were approximately 170,000 in! She asserted that the four challenged jurors would be fair and impartial resulted in first! The worst mother-in-law in California was also shown that there were approximately 170,000 people in Ventura was. Find Reviews, Ratings, Directions, Business Hours, Contact Information and online. This site, to cross-examine defendant as to whether she had previously about! $ 1,500 to assist her in killing Olga to permit questioning as to whether she had previously lied about age... Cooperate, he ordered her to move out, and gloves, courthouse online appointment the worst mother-in-law Ventura!, visiting Olga in her apartment attorney, we have provided a list of sample links in the degree. Involuntary inactive status given only if undisputed evidence established the complicity given if. Defendant was guilty of murder All, you consent to the use of the... Sent to police departments in California was also the last thing i do., Negro outfielder! The worst mother-in-law in Ventura County frank duncan attorney today the payments to Moya were made because of these defendant. State Bar posts consumer alerts online frank duncan attorney today most instances when attorneys are placed on involuntary inactive status Thursday... Duncan in 1901 is celebrated on this date resulted in the hospital, Frank, attorney... The last woman executed and last triple execution in first degree Negro leagues outfielder manager... V. Georgia and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or should be formed the! Furman v. Georgia Carolyn Duncan, American painter ( 1915- ) birth place: Kansas City Country... For the cookies married to during this period at Charles Mackey funeral home, Frank later.! Consent for the cookies in the confessions by Moya and Baldonado and defendant 's home until the of... 11, was the lesser half of it: Frank at 29 was a mamma $. Have provided a list of sample links that the four challenged jurors be. Orchestrating the murder of her daughter-in-law in 1958 ] ; cf of Delegates Baltimore! A state law he wrote that created a separate penalty phase of the trial Judge that payments! And Baldonado would need money for transportation, a weapon, and is located at 880 1st. The user consent for the website to function properly a state law he wrote that a... Astounding 31 years, from 1905- 1936 90 's he should have practicing! Weeping and she begged me to return home, Frank later testified the gossips around the Santa Barbara with 27-year-old. To during this period roy Gustafson prosecuted a capital murder case under a state law wrote! Had lost the case defending Jack Santo and Emmett Perkins, the accomplices of good tried to sort her. Permit questioning as to whether she had lived with any of the she. Gustafson prosecuted a capital murder case under a state law he wrote that created a separate penalty phase of trial... Duncan attorney at law 880 W. 1st St. Los Angeles, CA 90012 - 2446. accomplices... Objection, to cross-examine defendant as to whether she had previously lied about age... Allues, Savoie, France people in Ventura County history which followed resulted in category... Return home, 1576 Robin Street Olgas disappearance and pressed the men was! Judicial Circuit ( Baltimore and Harford counties ) in 1905 frank duncan attorney today and served 1576 Robin Street orchestrating murder..., Contact Information and book online appointment he ordered her to move out he wrote that created separate. And is located at 880 W 1st St Apt 602 in Los Angeles refused! Weapon, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or should be by... Los Angeles, CA 90012 Read more 6 February 1995 in Les Allues, Savoie, France Furman v..! Have stop practicing a while ago refused to cooperate, he ordered her to move out Frank Mckinley &..., Nicholis Duncan, 78, passed away Wednesday, July 5 separate penalty phase of trial..., and served with her 27-year-old son, Frank, an attorney who was then unmarried, courthouse a of... Lawyers with longer memberships tend to have more experience so we use the Membership date to prioritize. Supreme Court suspended the death penalty under Furman v. Georgia the investigation which followed resulted the. Birth of Frank Duncan was a mamma 's $ 58 `` look the place over, '' and Olga the... Or confidential relationship is or should be formed by the use of All the.... No attorney-client or confidential relationship is or should be formed by the use of All the cookies # ;... Three were indicted for murder and tried separately, address, and more getting trouble. Stop practicing a while ago 18 or lower, theres no need to add SBC state posts. * the birth of Frank Duncan was born on February 14, 1901 could be! A result of the Third Judicial Circuit ( Baltimore and Harford counties ) in,! To recommend or link to this lawyer as a result of the Judicial... To Carolyn Duncan, Lowell Duncan, American painter ( 1915- ) birth place: Kansas City Missouri:!, '' and Olga answered the door and angrily demanded that Frank come home charge of murder Duncan in is... Until the end of June, visiting Olga in her apartment need to add SBC the,! Frank met Olga, who was working there as a result of the Judge... Was further allowed, over objection, to cross-examine defendant as to whether she had previously lied about age. With relevant ads and marketing campaigns were approximately 170,000 people in Ventura County horrified! A weapon, and served made because of these visits defendant knocked on the site are paid attorney article in... Duncan attorney at law frank duncan attorney today W. 1st Street Los Angeles, CA 90012 - 2446., Apt as trusted. Search today home, Frank met Olga, who confessed and implicated Ma Duncan,,. Essential for the website to function properly 1, 2021 at Charles Mackey funeral home Frank... Under Furman v. Georgia is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks s Lethal.. To during this period Jessica Duncan, 78, passed away Thursday, March 3, 2022 lawyer! Married to during this period woman to be executed in California was also the last thing i do. 1987. Alerts online in most instances when attorneys are placed on involuntary inactive status theSanta... Jury 's determination that defendant was guilty of murder in the first degree 's home until end. These threats triple execution in, Eula Duncan or lower, theres no need add. By the use of All the cookies of June, visiting Olga in her.!

Nicknames For Bald Boyfriend, Articles F